Why does constitution provide for a weaker second chamber at state level when compared with that at union level? Analyse the significance of Legislative Council in states.
Sandeep Badad, AIR 82, 2025
Indian Constitution provides for bicameralism in Centre & states. However unlike in central legislature. state legislature does not mandatorily have the second chamber. The powers of the second chamber varies between center and state. The centre level second chamber is Rajya Sabha. => The centre level second chamber i.e is strong compared to state level second chamber i.e legislative council in following manner. 1. Existence of state legislative council (SLC) is prerogative of state legislature - under Art-246. unlike Rajya Sabha. 2. SLC have no role in constitutional amendments 3. SLCs can only delay the bill but cannot impose its will :- a dialatory chamber. 4. No provision of joint sitting as in Centre. 5. No powers w.r.to financial accountability of lower house 6. SLC doesnt have any sort of special powers unlike Rajya Sabha.
Rationale for second chamber is found in its => significance: - It acts as check on hasty legislation - It provides inputs & wisdom as the members are not under electoral compulsion. - It provides political space for eminent persons in various walks of life to participate in governance with their expertise.
=> However it is criticised for:- - It is largely used as backdoor entry for the political refugees. Ex:- Karnataka CM lost election & was brought back through SLC-nomination. - It has effectively failed to function in all the states where it exists. Ex:- W.Bengal abolished it.
Wisdom of Constitution makers was to include temperance in legislations by providing for a second chamber which could act as breaks at least for a while to contain the storm of hasty legislations. Going ahead it should be steengthened and can be remodelled on Rajya Sabha as chamber of local governments (PRIs). (Punchhi Commission)