What do you mean by 'doctrine of essentiality'? How has judiciary used this doctrine to address conflict between various fundamental rights? Explain with examples.
Sandeep Badad, AIR 82, 2025
Doctrine of essentiality means that only those element which are very basic and essential for faith are covered under the freedom of religion. It was first time mooted in Shirur Nath Case by SC.
This doctrine has been used to address conflict between various fundamental rights since then. Particularly it is b/w freedom of religion on one hand and other fundamental rights on the other. 1. In Sabarimala case where question of (Art-14) equality rose the court ruled in favour of equality using this doctrine. It is again in appeal. 2. Hijab case of Karnataka, the HC ruled that school uniform is compulsory and infereds wearing hijab as profession of religion. It addressed conflict between Art-21 and Art 25- citing mandatory uniform as reasonable Restriction. 3. Triple talaq case : SC ruled that it does not constitute as essential practice to protect right under Art-21 i.e right to dignity and liberty.
=> However it has attracted criticism due to: 1. How and who will decide what constitutes essential practice - is court competent with this respect? 2. Element of subjectivity in classifying any practice as essential 3. Against spirit of individual liberty and freedom of religion & secularism. 4. Negative fallouts:- affected education of girl children in hijab case, domino effect in Sabrimala case.
Matters concerned with religion cannot be dealt by institution of people like civil society instead of imposition by courts even though it is justifiable. Because consensus is essential for such change. => The principle of constitutional morality must be evoked among the general public to inspire change from bottom. Art-44 i.e. bringing in uniform civil code comes under legislative ambit casting duty on state not judiciary. Parliament needs to act to balance secularism and fundamental rights.