Topper Copies

Belief that the Indian constitution is a borrowed constitution is nothing but a myth. Discuss

Sandeep Badad, AIR 82, 2025

Indian Constitution was inspired by many of the contemporary constitutions of that time. => It fittingly has elements drawn from the constitutions of various nations. - British:- The political part is largely drawn from British. The parliamentary system, office of speaker, rule of law etc - USA:- Fundamental rights, Independent judiciary. V. President Office - France:- The ideas of liberty, equality, fraternity - USSR:- Fundamental duties - Ireland:- Directive principles. - Australia:- sitting, Freedom of interstate trade & commerce ; - S. Africa:- Amendment procedure - German-Weimar: Emergency provisions.

=> However the borrowing was not blind imitation. Rather the ideas were picked and modified to suit to the needs & aspirations of India. - Art 39A was directly drawn from Irish Catholic constitution & shelved into secular constitution of India. - Adopted parliamentary form but tempered it with judicial independence. Unlike parliamentary supremacy we have constitutional supremacy. - Blend of rigidity and flexibility in amendment. unlike rigid Constitn of USA or to flexible constitution of Britain. - Federalism:- sui generis - of its own kind too balance out integration of nation and autonomy of regions. unlike USA - Indian Constitution was only country that enfranchised all its adult population at one stroke in the beginning unlike USA, Britain & many others. - Our secularism is that of Minimal distance based unlike strict secularism of France & USA.

Thus, it is myth that ours was just a borrowed one. As B.R. Ambedkar puts it " there is no patent right on basic ideas. to pick them & modify to suit us is no plagiarism."