Topper Copies

Belief that the Indian constitution is a borrowed constitution is nothing but a myth. Discuss

Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025

Indian constitution is the longest-written constitution in the world which borrowed provisions from constitutions of many different countries.

Borrowed constitution

- From Government of India Act, 1935 - federalism, judiciary, public service commissions etc. - Features like parliamentary form of government, & cabinet system etc from Britain - U.S.A's constitution became the source of fundamental rights, independence of judiciary, impeachment process of President and Vice President for Indian constitution. - constitutions of USSR (fundamental duties), Canada (strong centre, central appointment of governor, residuary power with centre etc.), Japan and France also had a lasting impression on India's constitution.

However, Indian constitution is not merely a copy paste work. Drafted over a period of 2 years 11 months and 18 days, it was a product of intense deliberations and debates -

- Provisions from constitutions of other countries were moulded to suit the needs of independent India. For example, parliamentary sovereignty was harmonized with judicial supremacy. - It marked harmonization of western ideas with Indian traditions which is reflected in the Gandhian, socialist and liberal-intellectual principles of DPSP. - Founding fathers created an expansive document based on best practices of the world & which was required for a geographically vast and socially pluralistic society of independent India.

Thus, Indian constitution was not a borrowed document but a hallmark of ideological innovation to suit Indian needs.