Governor of a state enjoys more discretionary power than the president of India. Elaborate and explain the rationale behind this constitutional arrangement.
Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025
Article 163 states that governor shall act as per the aid and advice of council of ministers except when he is acting "in his discretion."
| President's Discretion | Governor's Discretion | | --- | --- | | 1. Enjoys only situational discretion like inviting member of largest party to form government when PM dies suddenly, dismissing council of ministers upon loss of majority and dissolving the Lok Sabha | 1. Besides ALSO enjoying situational discretion, governor has other powers like reserving bills for President's consideration, recommending imposition of President's rule, when he is acting as an administrator of an adjoining UT. | | 2. Bound to act as per aid & advice of council of ministers in all other matters (42nd constitutional amendment act) | 2. Not bound by the advice of council of ministers. |
Rationale behind this arrangement -
1. Principle of collective responsibility - The council of ministers and not the President are responsible to the Lok Sabha. Thus, has to act as per their advice 2. Governor as a representative of centre - in the states to ensure that governance is as per constitutional provisions (mandate under Article 355) 3. At the level of states, increasing administrative complexities require governor's discretion for seamless solutions. 4. Upholding federalism whilst ensuring national unity and stability - Governor's discretion is to be exercised to reconcile the two.
However, there are increasing instances of abuse of discretionary powers by the governor (Ex. in Manipur elections 2017, invited second largest party to form government)
As noted by SC in Nebia Rehman Judgment, this power should be exercised with caution and restraint.