Examine the role of the Finance Commission in maintaining the fiscal equilibrium in the country. Also, compare the recommendation of the 15th Finance commission with its predecessor and implications of its recommendations.
Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025
Finance Commission (Article 280) is a constitutional and quasi judicial body which acts as a balancing wheel of India's fiscal federalism.
ROLE OF FINANCE COMMISSION IN MAINTAINING FISCAL EQUILIBRIUM -
1. Provides for distribution of "net proceeds" of taxes between the centre and states & among states. - Vertical devolution -> of 41% of taxes (to be transferred to states.) by 15th FC. - Horizontal devolution -> determined based on criteria like income distance (45%), population change (12.5%), population (15%), Tax efforts (2.5%), area, forest cover. 2. Establishes principles that govern grants-in-aid to states. 3. Measures to augment consolidated Fund of State to increase devolution of resources to local bodies. 4. Any other matter referred by President.
15th FC Recommendations vs. 14th FC -
1. Vertical devolution of net proceeds of taxes has been reduced by 1% by the 15th FC compared to 42% of 14th FC. 2. Weightage to tax effort, demographic change, population etc. has been maintained at same levels. 3. Local Bodies - Performance linked grants have been reduced for ULBs and completely abolished for PRIs. 4. Revenue deficit grants are being faced out. 5. Both 14th and 15th FC took 2011 census to determine population related criterias for horizontal devolution.
IMPLICATIONS OF RECOMMENDATIONS -
1. Being an advisory body, recommendations are not binding on the government. For example, only 30% devolution vs. 41% recommendation of FC. 2. Clamour of Southern states => argue excessive weightage given to population and poverty. - Unfair to states sincerely implementing population control measures. 3. Very little weightage given to tax effort (2.5) which fails to incentivize such efforts by state. 4. For local bodies, failed to tap the transformational potential of performance-linked grants. - High weightage to population and area defeats the goal of equity w.r.t grants to local bodies.
WAY FORWARD
1. FC should be given a permanent status. 2. Weightage of 2011 census can be reduced and 1971 census should be given some weightage. 3. Reform-linked grants to states. 4. FC needs to shift approach away from gap-filling to "equalisation" (devolution among states at comparable levels if there are comparable efforts)
The architecture of fiscal federalism in India needs to be restructured on 4 pillars of FC, Niti Aayog, fairness of GST and decentralisation.