What do you understand by the First Past the Post System (FPPS)? Why was FPPS preferred over the Proportional Representation (PR) system for elections to the Lok Sabha/Vidhan Sabha? Also, critically examine the consequences of this preference.
Sandeep Badad, AIR 82, 2025
First Past the Post System is an electoral system where the candidate who secures highest number of votes among the contestants gets elected. It is not necessarily by majority of votes. - Eg:- 4 Candidates contesting, 1000 votes polled - Cand. A -> 312 votes - B -> 128 votes - C -> 439 votes => highest votes => gets elected (43% votes not majority). - D -> 121 votes
FPPS was preferred over Proportional Representation systems; 1. FPPS was simple & easy to understand. 2. Experience in pre-independence times. 3. The vast majority of people were illiterate & new to elections. 4. It pinned responsibility to an individual for a constituency 5. Continous check through elections while PRS. ie midterm or state election-
while PR suffered from various issues :- 1. Difficult to understand particularly new born India's illiterate mass. 2. No idea of responsible respresentative for a constituency - this would create disconnect b/w representative & people. 3. The diverse plural society could lead to political factios if PR system was adopted. Thereby severly affecting stability & development
Thus our Constitutional makers prefered FPPS over PRS.
Consequences of adopting FPPS: +ve consequence 1. India as a large democracy has endured despite surprising by entire global north & is thriving. 2. Individual responsibility for a constituency fared well in developing. eg MPLAD, MLALAD, many elected reps worked immensly to develop their constituency 3. Electoral check:- If govt is not functioning profesly people expressed disapproval in mid-term or bypolls. 4. FPPS ensured every adult to participate in democratic process. 5. Democratic consolidation:- Mandal politics & rise of BSP
-ve Consequences 1. Vote bank politics: Election become number game & caste, religion was used for garnering support. 2. This led to divisive tendencies & social disharmony - eg:- Babri masjid, Godhra riots 3. Criminalisation of politics:- Candidates were selected based on winnability rather than merit. 4. Extensive use of money power. eg Lokniti CDS report says 16th LS flowed "[?] 000 crs" 5. Political opportunism:- Aaya Ram Gaya Ram culture 6. FPPS & electoral compulsions kept capable, intellectual & dedicated persons away from electoral politics. 7. FPPS - Prime reason for corruption as electoral compulsion necessitates & becomes foundation of entire infrastructure of corruption (2nd ARC)
=> Right after Independence, FPPS was suitable in context of national unity & integrity. Having thrived & endured so far, the need is to weed out shortcomings & explore alternatives like mixed model proportional [?]