Despite the presence of a plethora of development schemes, India lags behind in creating a prosperous society. Is it a design issue or an implementation bottleneck? What suggestions would you make to improve the performance of developmental schemes?
Sandeep Badad, AIR 82, 2025
Over successive governments there have been array of developmental schemes with strategies evolving from providential model to facilitator model yet India lags behind creating prosperous society as indicated by => - Global Hunger Index -> 145/165 rank - Poverty -> 370 mn people - MMR -> 135 - U5MR -> 35 etc. - Unemployment -> 7.1 rate.
Reasons for limited sucess of developmental scheme. => Design and planning issues. 1. Multiplicity of agencies working in silos. - Eg:- Ministry of social justice, Ministry of Tribal affairs although have similar mandate work in isolation. 2. No institutional mechanism to get inputs for planning from top to bottom. PRI exists but largely disfunctional at planning level. 3. Highly centralised planning & design. 4. Lack of coherence between Centre & State as health, police, agriculture etc is under state list. 5. Planning Commission failed to deliver balanced growth. 6. Lack of futuristic prespective due to myopic political considerations eg farm loans waivers 7. Poor mechanism of policy evaluation and correction.
=> Implementation Bottlenecks. 1. Rigid hierarchy - delayed action. 2. Corruption - poor transmission of benefits - eg only 10 paise/100 reached the beneficiaries 3. Beneficiary: fake ids, inefficient targetting - eg fake Jan-Dhan accounts. 4. Lax action by authorities & poor accountability mechanisms. eg MGREGA muster rolls. 5. Lack of responsiveness:- Many offices [?] - Eg Jharkhand PDS case during COVID-19 yet to adopt charters. 6. Inadequate grievance redressal mechanism.
=> Thus it is due to [mix of both] design & implementation issues
Suggestions to improve performance of developmental scheme. 1. Bottom-up approach in design. Involve PRI & Civil societies in planning & design fucs. eg GPDP 2. Decentralise & delegate:- Creates sense of agency in local authorities & easy to hold accuntable for local people. Improves efficiency & effectiveness. - eg 14 FC - 42% devolution is welcome step 3. Technology:- Digitisation to prevent leakages & corruption, increase responsivenes eg Jan-dhan-adhaar linkage, DBT 4. Capability approach (Amartya Sen) by given choice eg PM KISAN, Skill India Mission, Ayushman Bharat, Beti bachao Beti padao, Tribal haat, Eklavya Model Residency School. 5. Capacity building & sensitisation among public servants 7. Encourage greater involvement of Civil society by institutionalising social audit, citizen report card into the CAG audit report.