Topper Copies

Why was parliamentary form of government adopted for independent India? Do you agree with the opinion that Indian government is increasingly transitioning towards presidential form? Justify.

Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025

Parliamentary form of government is one in which the executive is responsible to the legislature and the head of government is different from the head of state.

Reasons for adopting parliamentary form of government

1. Familiarity with this form of government owing to Government of India Act of 1919 and 1935. 2. Preference for responsibility over stability - as executive can be effectively controlled by the legislature through parliamentary committees, instruments like adjournment motion etc. 3. It ensures harmony between legislature and the executive. Tussle between these two organs would have been fatal for a nascent democracy like India. 4. Ensures wide representation - as members are from every nook and cranny of India. Being so vast and pluralistic, Indian democracy could have only survived through effective CONSENSUS BUILDING. 5. Prevented despotism as powers were dispersed in a group (Executive) rather than one person (PM).

However, in recent times, some tenets of parliamentary form of government have been violated -

1. Increasing excesses of power by executive through laws like UAPA and due to a weak opposition. 2. Rise of personality cult of PM such that political parties are identified by a person rather than the electoral manifesto. 3. With a majority in the Parliament, the government enjoys an "automatic majority" leading to a submissive legislature.

Shift Towards Presidential form ?

However, it cannot be stated that Indian government is transitioning towards a Presidential form of government -

1. Principle of collective responsibility (A. 75) is an effective check to ensure that only a government that enjoys confidence of legislature stays in power. 2. No strict separation of powers which ensures checks and balances -> Thus, judiciary ensures executive and legislative organs functions within constitutional contours.

Parliamentary form of government is the bedrock of Indian democracy. Each organ should uphold its constitutional duty while working together towards nation-building.