Topper Copies

Discuss the role of parliamentary financial committees in ensuring executive accountability to the parliament.

Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025

Parliamentary committees are "mini-legislatures" which perform specialized functions. They may be ad-hoc or standing and act as tools for effective check of legislature on the executive.

PARLIAMENTARY FINANCIAL COMMITTEES

1. Public Accounts Committee - Comprising of 22 members (15 in LS and 7 in RS), this committee examines the Appropriation account, finance account and other accounts of the government. It also examines reports of CAG not only on government's accounts but all financial matters. Further, it looks into accounts of state corporations, manufacturing projects etc. 2. Committee on Public Undertakings - examines accounts of PSUs to ensure that they are being run as per sound business principles and prudent commercial policies. 3. Estimates committee - examines the budget estimates of the government and suggests economies in public expenditure. It ensures that money for policies is within the limits of the estimate and suggests alternate policies, reforms in organization and administration.

ROLE IN ENSURING EXECUTIVE ACCOUNTABILITY

1. Ministers are not part of these committees. 2. They maintain a close and continuous check on governments finances and thereby enforce collective responsibility. 3. Deepen democracy as members are not subject to party whip & defection laws. Thus, open debate takes place without politicisation of issues. 4. Specialised knowledge - as committees can invite experts. Ex. Raghuram Rajan by finance committee to decide on demonetization. 5. Detailed scrutiny of bills to ensure they are not ultra-vires. 6. As parliament is too big and unwieldy, real enforcement of collective responsibility happens through finance committees.

However, role of finance committees need to be strengthened -

1. Short tenure of 1 year prevents specialisation 2. Members lack technical expertise to deal with financial matters. 3. Politicisation of issues. 4. High vacancies and fewer bills getting referred to committee.

WAY FORWARD

Parliamentary committees should be strengthened by mandatory reference of bills, extention of tenure beyond 1 year and continuous monitoring to ensure highest-standard are upheld.