Topper Copies

Analyse the reasons for degeneration of parliamentary functioning in recent time. Also, suggest measure to make the parliament more productive.

Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025

Article 79 of the constitution provides for a Parliament consisting of Lower House (directly elected) and Upper House (indirectly elected and represents states).

DEGENERATION OF PARLIAMENTARY FUNCTIONING

1. Criminalisation of politics leading to poor quality of legislations. Ex. marital rape in Prohibition of Domestic Violence Act not illegal. - Majority of criminals are charged for heinous crimes like rape, murder etc.:

[a bar chart of the share of criminals in the Lower House: 30% in the 15th, 35% in the 16th and 43% in the 17th Lok Sabha] 2. Frequent use of ordinances to by-pass legislature. Ex. 25 C in Bihar between 1967-1981 3. Average working days have reduced from 150 in 1950s to 67 between 2010-2020. 4. Fewer bills referred to Parliamentary committees (reduced from 71% in 15th LS to 25% in 16th LS) 5. Biased role of speaker bypassing Rajya Sabha by resorting to money bill route. Ex. Recent amendment to PMLA. 6. Poor representation of women (only 78/543 in 17th LS), LGBTQ community and other minorities. 7. Frequent use of guillotine motion, fall in Parliamentary ethics, hasty passage of legislation (Ex. Reservation for EWS Bill passed without distributing to legislators)

MEASURES TO MAKE PARLIAMENT MORE PRODUCTIVE -

1. Passage of Parliament (Enhancement of Productivity) Bill, 2017 -> Minimum work for 100 days and no compensation for hours lost due to disruption 2. Electoral reforms to decriminalize Parliament and break criminal-politician-police nexus (Padmanabhaiah Committee) 3. Constructive role of opposition. 4. Mandatory reference of bills to Parliamentary committee.

Parliamentary reforms are essential to uphold electoral democracy and ensure good governance.