Topper Copies

The Election Commission of India has a vital role in building a robust framework of electoral democracy. Highlighting challenges associated with the functioning of ECI, suggest measures to reform the body.

Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025

Election Commission of India (A.324) is a critical pillar of our democracy that ensures free and fair elections, which are transparent and voter-centric.

CHALLENGES FACED BY ECI

1. ECI has had limited success in curbing the twin menaces of criminalisation and communalisation of elections. As per ADR, 49% of MPs in 17th Lok Sabha face criminal charges.

2. Lack of Power - Cannot disqualify contestors for electoral malpractice or de-register parties. Further, MCC has no statutory backing. 3. Structural issues - Executive arbitrariness in appointment of chief election commissioner. - dependence on central and state governments for manpower. 4. Constitutional loopholes - Constitution does not mention its term & qualifications. Further, there is no bar on reappointment. - Expenditure is not charged on Consolidated Fund of India. 5. Issues related to malfunctioning of EVMs and only ~67% voter turnout in 2019 LS elections.

MEASURES TO REFORM ECI

1. Appointment through a collegium of PM, Speaker, Deputy chairman, Leader of opposition and Law Minister (255th Law Commission & 2nd ARC) 2. Security of tenure to election commissioners also (T. N. Seshan Case). 3. Bar on reappointment 4. Independent secretariat for functioning. 5. Idea of giving MCC a statutory backing can be explored. 6. Expenditure should be charged on consolidated fund of India.

Effective functioning of ECI is critical to uphold Indian democratic traditions and ensure a sanitary political culture.