Topper Copies

"Rape is a rape; it cannot be condoned on the basis of the marital relationship between the victim and the accused." In light of the statement, throw light on the ongoing debate regarding the criminalization of marital rape.

Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025

Recently a two judges bench of Delhi HC gave a split verdict on criminalisation of Marital Rape spawning Debate.

Marital Rape Exemption (MRE)

-> Section 75(2) of BNS does not consider rape by husband of her wife as rape for purpose of Criminal law

Ongoing Debate

A) Need to criminalise Marital Rape

1. MRE allows for Subjugation of women by husband 2. Rise of Spousal violence cases - NFHS-V -> 29.3% women experience Spousal Sexual violence 3. Imposes Victorian Morality above constitutional morality 4. Against dignity and Right to Choice (Art 21) of women. 5. Rape is Rape -> even if it is husband 6. Allow husband to be placed above rule of law + equality

B) Debate Against

1. To preserve institution of marriage 2. Might lead to false criminalisation - eg Section 497 - dowry misused 3. Marriage itself comes with certain rights and duties 4. Against Stability of society and family 5. Difficult to prove otherwise

Way forward

1. Justice Verma Committe 1. Criminalisation of Marital Rape 2. Shedding away Victorian Patriarchy 2. Providing checks in law to address misuse concerns. 3. Strict counter-punishment for wrong cases.

Dignity and respect to women is key idea of our constitution, thus we must criminalise marital Rape