Lateral entry into civil services is seen as a reformative step, yet it continues to attract criticism and controversy. Discuss.
Ujjwal Priyank, AIR 10, 2025
The Baswan committee for civil services reform advocated for lateral entry into civil services.
However, there are various criticism and controversy over lateral entry due to following factors: 1) Lateral entry will lead to domination of civil services by specific interest groups. 2) Administration is not only about efficiency and expertise. → It is about generalised outlook towards society for governance with empathy. 3) It dilutes the spirit of achievement oriented meritocratic society. 4) Lateral entry can lead to dilution of civil services value
Thus reforms must be brought rather than changing the entire bureaucratic structure
1) Hota committee recommendation for 360° evaluation of civil servants 2) Training should be based on building values. Eg: Mission Karmayogi 3) Providing ethical values for inclusive and good governance.
The committee on the working of constitution correctly observed, that "some generalist must be specialised"