An archaic and obsolete edifice of civil services does not augur well for a welfare state. Examine the various issues surrounding the civil services in the country. What suggestions would you make for their reform?
Maurvie Tiwari, AIR 90, 2025
Civil services include a cadre of paid, permanent, professional and qualified officials who constitute the administrative wing of the government. Articles 308 - 314 in Part 14 of the constitution contain provisions related to them.
SIGNIFICANCE OF CIVIL SERVICES
- Expansion in role of the government due to scientific and technological revolutions as well as new challenges such as haphazard urbanization, unequal economic growth - Thus, they play a crucial role in dispensing social services - Stabilising force - Ensure continuity in administration - Bridge between citizens aspirations and outcome of government initiatives.
However, several issues are plaguing the edifice of civil services today -
1. Overinvolved in routine tasks, lack of cross-departmental coordination, risk avoidance and delays in decision making due to multiple veto points in hierarchy (2nd ARC). 2. Lack of dynamism due to "RULE - BOOK DEMOCRACY" wedded to their prospects and privileges, they overly rely on rules and procedures which leads to red tapism and delayed response to citizen's needs. - Further, they resist change. For example, this is a big reason for limited success of 73rd and 74th CAA -> changes are needed at district administration level. 3. Poor efficiency due to near automatic career progression. 4. Corruption and decline in values. Ex. Suspension of chief secretary of U.P. in 2012 over such charges. 5. Political interference also impairs their judgment leading to political patronage due to fear of transfer. Ex. Ashok Khemka transferred 53 times in 28 years. 6. Lack of openness to work collaboratively with CSOs, private sector etc. 7. Lack of technical expertise. 8. Vacancies (as many as 1500)
Following reforms can be initiated to transform civil services -
1. Lateral entries on a greater scale to challenge and increase efficiency of established civil service through competition (NITI Aayog Action Agenda) 2. Outcome-based goal setting with strict timelines for departments. 3. Postings as per skill sets. 4. Increase mid-career trainings to enhance domain expertise (2nd ARC) 5. Leverage ICT (Hota Committee 2004) 6. Replace Annual Confidential Report with Multi-Stakeholder Feedback. 7. Mandatory retirement of underperforming officers. 8. Recommendations of CIVIL SERVICE BOARD shouldn't be rejected.
Government steps like Mission karmayogi, total 5 mid-career trainings and lateral entry at JS level are steps in the right direction.
Reforms will ensure civil servants continue to be the "steel frame" of India.