BRICS can serve as a platform for shaping a post-Western global order, but the potential of the grouping is held back by internal contradictions. Examine.
Abhishek Sharma, AIR 38, 2024
BRICS - an acronym for Brazil, Russia, India, China & South Africa is a plurilateral grouping with an objective of changing current world order & restructuring global economy
Potential as a platform for post Western global order
1. Reformed multilateralism - addressing the "freezing the moment" problem. - UNSC reforms 2. New Development Bank acting as a substitute of World Bank (western hegemony) 3. Contingency Reserve arrangement to deal with Balance of Payment crisis as a substitute to IMF unilaterally imposing Washington Consensus 4. Reflects modern demography & economic considerations
[two pie charts: 45% of global population in BRICS; 33% of global GDP]
5. It contains modern & rising superpowers challenging the traditional US-led order. 6. Contains middle powers like India, BRAZIL, S-Africa which are considerate to the needs of global South.
Limitations & Internal Contradictions
1. Democracy vs Authoritarianism - It contains both, pure democracies like India and borderline authoritarian governments like China & Russia. 2. Different strategic priorities - China & Russia - to counter USA - India - to develop global south - Saudi Arabia + UAE - pro USA 3. Different modus-operandi - India uses soft power - China uses hard power. 4. Internal Conflicts b/w India & China - Iran & S. Arabia etc.
Thus, for BRICS to become the new reality and the centre of post western world it must work towards forging the Convergences & managing the divergences.