While rankings aim to benchmark the performance of Higher Education Institutions (HEIs), concerns remain about whether current ranking frameworks reflect the broader goals of education. Suggest measures to make the ranking system more objective, inclusive, and aligned with educational and societal outcomes.
Vaibhav Singh, AIR 82, 2024
The HEI rankings by national level and international level organisations provide a necessary information to prospective students and employees while making a decision on education and placements. However, their methodologies generate some concerns.
HEI Ranking Framework
1. Some prominent HEI rankings seek to quantify educational outcomes and associated parameters to benchmark performance of institutions. 2. Prominent parameters are: - a) public and student perception - b) number of publications by teachers - c) employment and learning outcomes of students - d) infrastructure, etc.
Problems in Frameworks
1. Different weights are allocated to different parameters in a non-transparent manner and data-collection is usually not very credible. 2. Moreover, such quantification does not reflect the real purpose of education. 3. It curbs scope for creativity and leads institutions into a rat race of competing over set parameters. 4. Furthermore, it does not consider the more innate dimensions of education - of making morally sound and responsible citizens.
While the need for rankings of certain minimum quantifiable data is not questionable, it has to be done in a more transparent and streamlined manner. Additionally, one should keep in mind the ideas of Tagore when he set up Viswa Bharat'. Education should be about irrigating the deserts rather than cutting the forests. (CS Lewis).