Topper Copies

Differentiate between the clemency powers of the Presidents of India and the USA. Also, critically examine the vesting of clemency power in the executive.

Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025

While India follows a parliamentary form of governance, US follows a Presidential form impacting clemency power.

Similarity

-> Both vested in respective Presidents -> His decision is final

| Aspect | USA | India | |---|---|---| | 1) Independent power | Yes | No, only on advice of Council of Ministers | | 2) Judicial Review | Not allowed | Allowed (Kehar Singh Case) | | 3) Basis | general laws | Constitution (Article 72) | | 4) Checks & Balance | No checks on President's power | Proper checks by executive & Judiciary | | 5) Frequency | More used | Sparingly used | | 6) Extent of power | only federal crimes | Can pardon death even under state law | | 7) purpose | Mostly personal eg Joe Biden's Son pardoned | To remove Travesity of Justice |

Need of Clemancy power

1. Human Touch to Judicial System (SC in Kehar Singh case) 2. Preventing Travesity of Justice by the Judiciary 3. Providing last resort to convicts to reform Themself 4. Promote Healing in Society - eg Demand for Rajjona Case pardon -> Sikh healing

Issues with executive clemancy

1. leads to personal favoritism eg Joe Biden's Case 2. Promote caste and communal based clemancy. 3. Blurs separation of power -> executive clemancy 4. Challenge to authority of the Court

Way forward

As Supreme-Court has highlighted in Maru Ram Case, [?] should not act as court of appeal & only provide clemancy in case of visible injustice.