Bring out the rationale behind the introduction and implementation of the three new criminal laws. Highlighting key features of the laws, state the associated concerns.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
from 1 July, 2024, India has adopted three new criminal laws
Rational behind
1. Doing away with colonial legacy - part of 'Panch Puan' of Pm Modi 2. Changing perspective -> from state centric colonial laws to people centric modern laws 3. Evolution with changing times - eg Recognition to mob lynching, organised crimes 4. Ensuring Speedy trials and faster criminal justice delivery - eg 90 days time limit for courts 5. Adopting & incorporating Judicial pronoucement - eg Against Adultury - Removed in BNSS
Key features
A) Bhartiya Nyay Samhita
1. Introduction of New crimes eg organized crime 2. Women centricism eg Section 75 strict punishment for Rape 3. fading colonial legacy eg Removal of Sedition
B) Bhartiya Nagarik Surakhsha Samhita
1. Introduction of community service as punishment 2. Proper Time frame -> from hearing to decision
C) Bhartiya Sakhya Samhita
1. Allow digital evidence as primary evidence 2. Allowing online video conferencing of accused
Associated Concerns
1. No major change - "Cut, copy, Paste Reforms" - P. Chidambaram 2. Abhishek Singhvi -> Might play with judicial evolution of sections interpreted over time 3. Difficulty for lawyers and judges 4. Disguised provision eg Section 152 of BNS - like Sedition provision 5. Higher police custody - 60 days - custodial violence concern 6. use of deepfake in online evidence
Way forward
1. Establishing new forensic university 2. Comprehensive Reform eg Criminalise Marital Rape 3. Steady implementation of the reforms.