Parliamentary privileges are fundamental for lawmakers to discharge their duties without undue influence. However, ensuring the responsible exercise of these privileges is crucial for fostering public trust and ensuring the accountability of public institutions. Analyse.
Abhishek Sharma, AIR 38, 2024
Parliamentary Privileges are extra powers, rights and privileges given to houses of the Parliament, its committees and its members for effective discharge of their functions.
Fundamental for lawmakers
1. Strengthen legislature to freely hold the executive accountable. 2. empower MPs to ensure substantive representation of people. 3. Prevent them from judicial consequences for discharge of their duties. e.g - Prevent asymmetric incentives. 4. Enhanced scrutiny of laws -> better quality of legislations. 5. maintain the sanctity and secrecy of the house.
However, there are certain issues vis-a-vis exercise of parliamentary privileges
1. Not codified by the Parliament (as provided in Article 105(2)) 2. ambiguous & vague - misused by parliamentarians. 3. Reduced sanctity of the house. - e.g - JMM bribery incident 4. increased hate speech, false allegations under the garb of free speech.
Ensuring responsible exercise of privileges
1. Recently Supreme Court in Sita Soren Case said :- Privileges will be protected from judicial review only if - twin test: part of collective functioning of the house; part of duties of the MP. 2. NCRWC suggested codification of the privileges. 3. MPs themselves must not misuse the privileges.
Parliament is the "temple of democracy" and its sanctity and effective functioning depends on responsible use of Parliament-ary Privileges.