"The Basic Structure Doctrine, lauded for safeguarding the core principles of the Constitution against majoritarian impulses, is also criticized for enabling judicial overreach and disturbing the balance of power as envisioned by the Constitution." Elaborate.
Abhishek Sharma, AIR 38, 2024
Basic Structure doctrine as proposed by judiciary in Keshavananda Bharti case (1973), protects the fundamental features of the Constitution from amending power of the Parliament.
Safeguarding the core principles of the constitution.
1. It prevented "rewriting" of the constitution by majoritarian governments as per whims. 2. It upheld & protected checks & balances by protecting Judicial Review. 3. It protected Indian democracy - e.g - Free & Fair elections - part of Basic structure - (Raj Narain Case) 4. It upheld individual as the focal point of the constitution. - e.g - Liberty, equality part of Basic Structure. 5. It led to progressive realization of human rights. - e.g - A-20 & 21 part of Basic structure.
Enabling Judicial Overreach & disturbing balance of power
1. It has led to "tyranny of the unelected" - Arun Jaitley - e.g - Supreme court striking down NJAC (99th constitutional Amendment) 2. Tilted the balance of power in favor of judiciary -> overarching power. - "Judiciary becoming 3rd chamber" - KK Venugopal 3. "Open sword in the hands of judiciary" -> no fixed list as to what constitutes basic structure (decided by the judges). - -> "extra constitutional doctrine"
However,
Limited use by judiciary
1. There have been 60+ amendments after Keshavananda Bharti case
and even in those six, the provision curtailing Judicial review was struck down.
So despite its limitations, basic structure doctrine has been successful in preserving Indian democracy and the ideals & aspirations of our Constitution makers.