Simultaneous elections are advocated as a step towards reforming the electoral process and streamlining governance; however, their broader implications for democracy and federalism remain contentious. Discuss.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
Recently, Parliament sent the bill for introduction of simultaneous election to Parliamentary Standing committee for further deliberation.
Simultaneous Election
- Together conduction of State & federal election - Simultaneous voting - Single electoral roll
A step toward reform
A) Reforming electoral process
1. Helps to come out from continuous cycle of election 2. Reduce electoral expenses - CMS Report - 18th LS cost - Rs 1.3 lakh crore 3. Streamlines electoral roll and entire electoral process 4. Single one time disruption only.
B) Streamlining governance
1. Reduces governance cost of implementing Model Code (MCC) 2. leads to fundamental reforms instead of populist policy due to election 3. Admistrative efficiency - No regular deployment of Army, CRPF, bureaucracy - limited loss of government personal hours eg teacher in election work
Contentious Implication
1) for Democracy
1. Against principle of continuous accountability 2. government once elected may turn authoritarian 3. Overstated benefits to people - no substantial benefit 4. would require dismissal of democratically elected government for initial fine tuning
2) for federalism
1. Will favour national parties more - eg - IDFC Survey Result 2. Against federalism -> centre might impose extended President Rule to ensure simultaneous election 3. local issues would get sidelined by national issues
Way forward
1. NITI Suggestion -> Clubbing all the election in a year together 2. Piecemeal Reforms 3. SY Quereshi -> Capping Party expenses to solve money use problem