Topper Copies

Explain how the terms 'socialist' and 'secular' in the Preamble embody specific meanings in the Indian context.

Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025

Recently while dismissing petition against removal of 'Social' and 'secular' Supreme Court highlighted the special meaning of terms in Indian context.

Specific Meaning of Socialist

1. SC in Nakara vs UOI -> Indian Model is compromise between Gandhian & Marxist Socialism (tilting toward Gandhian) 2. Doesn't abolish private ownership (SC in Property owner Association Case) 3. Establishes a welfare State (Art 38) 4. focuses on upliftment of poor and Vulnerable Section 5. Duty bound state to ensure redistribution (Article 39)

Specific Meaning of Secularism

1. Based on idea of 'Sarva Dharam Sambhav' (Article 25)

2. Allows state intervention for religious reform - eg Banning of Sati, Triple Talaq 3. formation of endowment funds - eg Waqf Act by centre 4. freedom to practice, profess & propagate religion 5. Special Rights for the minority eg Article 30.

Thus, we donot follow western Convention of the term and things are different for India