The collegium system of judicial appointments remains the best mechanism to safeguard the judiciary's independence. Critically examine.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
In NJAC Case (2015), Supreme Court upheld Collegium System and declared independence of Judiciary as part of Basic structure of constitution
Collegium = Best Mechanism
1. upholds Judicial independence in appointment 2. In line with Article 50 of constitution 3. Judges have best knowledge of internal functioning of Judiciary. 4. Evolved Transparency in Procedure by 3 Judges Case 5. Presence of 5 Judges in panel -> prevents any mis-judgement
Issues with system
1. leading to favouritism and Nepotism in Judiciary - "uncle judges syndrome" 2. Invisible Amendment -> Not in original Constitution 3. lack of representation of vulnerable Section - eg only 11.1% women in HCs 4. Unnecessary delay -> executive sitting on recommendation 5. unparallel in world -> most country have min of executo-judicial app[?]
Way forward
- Transparency in selection Procedure - Quota to ensure representation - Signing MoU with centre
Judicial independence is sin-qua-non while bring any reforms in system