Recent controversies over alleged malpractices in the electoral rolls have renewed demands for the mandatory linkage of Aadhaar with Voter ID. What is your opinion? Give reasons in support of your answer.
Vaibhav Singh, AIR 82, 2024
The recent allegations of large-scale fake voter-ID generation that have come to fore post SIR (special intensive revision) in Bihar and allegations by opposition on voting malpractice in Maharashtra have restarted discussions on due diligence in voter-ID generation.
Aadhaar-Voter ID Linkage
1. The idea is to weed out more than one voter-ID of same person by Aadhar linkage. 2. Since Aadhar is linked to biometric identity, more than one Aadhar cannot be generated for the same person.
The Pros of Linkage
1. Linkage with aadhar would automatically weed out Voter IDs of dead or non-existent voters often used to commit fraud in voting. 2. Furthermore, the linkage of Aadhar with the newly formed Registrar General's records would ensure automatic voter id cancellation in event of death. 3. This would also allow voter to easily transfer voter id to a new destination by only changing aadhar address.
The Cons of Linkage
1. The linkage with aadhar would jeopardise voters identity and secrecy by employing facial recognition and other technologies for voter verification at polling booths. 2. It might make voters profiling easier and hence voter susceptible to social engineering by national, international actors.
The Way Forward
1. The provision of linkage can be a boon if implemented with high credibility and fairness. 2. Aadhar-Voter id linkage can be done using token ID numbers that are stored then on a distributed secure blockchain ledger. 3. Moreover, newer quantum-proof encryption technologies can be used. Furthermore, biometric authentication at polling booth may not be done - with aadhar only used to very voter id at time of generation.
The existing ECI guidelines allow for voluntary linkage. By streamlining and securing aadhar generation as well, this project can be furthered with all Party Consensus.