Topper Copies

Critically examine the 'in-house procedure' adopted by the Apex Court to inquire into allegations of misconduct against judges of constitutional courts in India.

Vaibhav Singh, AIR 82, 2024

The recently concluded unsuccessful challenge to the in-house inquiry procedure of the Supreme Court by Justic Yashwant Verma has reiterated the sanctity of the same and reignited debates around it.

The In-House Procedure

1. The in-house procedure of 1999 of the Supreme Court lays down guidelines on inquiring the cases of mis-conduct of judges of High Courts and the Supreme Court. 2. It allows for formation of three membered committees comprising HC Chief Justices and judge of the Supreme Court in case of HC judge and Supreme Court judges in case of HC Chief Justice and Supreme Court judges. 3. The committee conducts initial inquiry into allegations and may make recommendation of impeachment against a judge to the parliament and the Government. 4. The inquiry procedure also allows in house preliminary remedies like taking away judicial functions, transfers, etc.

A Critical Analysis

1. The procedure has no constitutional or legal basis. 2. It goes against ideas of 'natural justice' and separation of powers as judiciary judges its own cases (e.g., allegations of sexual misconduct against then CJI that were dismissed). 3. However, at the same time, it allows for ensuring: - a) independence of judiciary. - b) prevention of frivolous allegations on judges - c) safeguards dignity of judges.

Way Forward

1. The procedure can be further streamlined by allowing a members of the Bar and the Legislature as part of the inquiry committee. 2. Procedural transparency and credibility needs to be enhanced to ensure public faith. Judiciary, having been given the responsibility of ensuring safety of constitutional values has a higher responsibility of fair conduct. Hence, it should not just be done but seen to be done as well