Is the growing demand for stricter regulation of online content justified, or does it pose a threat to the right to freedom of speech and expression? Examine in light of recent judicial pronouncements.
Vaibhav Singh, AIR 82, 2024
The recent controversy surrounding use of obscene language by some Stand up comedians online has reignited the debate around regulation of Speech and expression and about finding the right balance.
Online Content Regulation
1. While the upcoming IT Act is yet to see the light of the day, the 2000 IT Act continues to be the regulating power with the government. 2. The Supreme Court in the Shreya Singhal Case had outlawed Sec. 66A and raised the threshhold of initiating legal restrictions over online speech. 3. However, controversies surrounding dissemination of vulgar content (over 63 OTTs were banned) and usage of hate speech (Nuh Violence case) and vulgar speech (India's Got Latent case) reflect the need for regulation in interests of public order. 4. Article 19(2) too puts restrictions on 19(1)(a), ensuring that it does not threaten public safety, morality, sovereignty and India's friendly relations with other countries.
The Need for Balance
1. While regulation is needed to ensure safer digital space for the vulnerable and kids, its important to ensure that such regulation is limited and not arbitrary. 2. Industry-level self-regulation checks could be a better first step to prevent direct state intervention. 3. Similar checks by social media intermediaries that enjoy 'Safe-harbour protections' by ensuring algorithmic bias does not promote violence and hate speech. 4. An example of curbs placed by Britain on adult content through age verification to ensure safe space for children can be taken into consideration.
The goal of regulation needs to be to create safe space for expression and not censorship of Chinese nature. This required public participation and self-checks to ensure safety for all.