Throwing light on the constitutional provisions for safeguarding the autonomy of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG,) recommend measures to enhance its role as the conscience keeper of the government.
Abhishek Sharma, AIR 38, 2024
CAG (Comptroller & Auditor General) is a constitutional office under Article-148 of Indian Constitution. It is envisaged as a watchdog of Public purse.
Roles
Significance
1. Ensure accountability - audit of all accounts - finds irregularities 2. Promotes transparency - Reports placed in Parliament - Reports also accessible to general public 3. Reduces extravagance & wastage of public money - by Proprietary audits. 4. Acts as a deterrence against misuse of funds & corruption. 5. Suggests technical measures to local governments.
Constitutional provisions that safeguard the autonomy of CAG
1. Security of tenure -> 6/65 years. 2. Salary charged on the Consolidated fund of India. 3. Conditions of service can't be changed to disadvantage during the term. 4. Report to be submitted to President & tabled in the Parliament. 5. Constitutionally mandated audit of the accounts. 6. IAAS as a Central Civil services with considerable autonomy. 7. Separate autonomous staff & offices.
But there are certain limitations :-
Measures
- Vinod Rai commission under ex-CAG's chairmanship has suggested :- - Amendment of CAG Act - Collegium like system to appoint CAG on lines of CVC. - Making recommendations binding - Leveraging technology - Big data mining. - Depoliticization of the offices - giving more powers in certain areas eg CBI - Training & skill development of workforce.
Dr.B.R. Ambedkar had envisaged CAG as the single most important office created by the constitution.