How has asymmetric federalism helped India accommodate its diverse regional needs? Discuss with suitable examples.
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
"Indian federalism is quasi-federal" - KC Wheare
This quasi-federal nature helped to accomodate diverse Needs.
Role in accomodating needs
1. Tilt toward centre -> allow managing emergency & preventing succesionist tendency. 2. Population as basis allow for equitable distribution of seat 3. Positive affirmation against vulnerable States - eg Package for Bihar in Budget 2024-25. 4. Strengthen idea of "Ek-Bharat Shreshtha Bharat" - eg Tax by TN, Mah contributes to development of UP, Bihar 5. Allows centre to mediate and solve inter-state disputes - eg Kaveri, Inter-State River Dispute Board 6. Issues with approach - Excessive tilt -> unitary Structure - states feel discriminated - Against classical (US, Australia) Model of federalism
"Indian form is unique, in sense it evolved from debate, discussion & protest among federal units" - SC in Mohit Mineral Case