The evolution of property rights in India reflects an intricate relationship that exists between individual rights and public welfare. Discuss this statement with the help of relevant constitutional provisions and case laws.
Vaibhav Singh, AIR 82, 2024
The recent Supreme Court judgement in case of Mumbai Chawl Dwellers, has brought forth the debate on property right in India. A debate that started from the first amendment and continues even today.
Evolution of Property Rights
1. From being a fundamental right (Art. 19(1)(f) & 31) to being reduced to a legal, constitutional right (Art. 300A), Right to Property has troubled many a regimes in India. 2. Property rights came up as first hindrance during Zamindari Abolition push of the first government. With the Supreme Court upholding their sanctity in the Shankari Prasad Case, the Government added 9th schedule beyond remit of judicial review to undertake reforms. 3. When, in Golaknath Case, the non-amendability of fundamental rights was reiterated, the challenge emerged even more. 4. It was finally in the Keshavananda Bharati case, that the Supreme Court upheld amendment powers of the parliament while ensuring the basic structure is not altered. 5. In this background, the Bank Nationalisation Case (RC Cooper), highlighted the primacy of public welfare over individual rights (Art. 39(b) & (c)).
However, the recent judgement by Supreme Court puts a stringent assessment for defining public welfare and creates a greater threshold for invading individual rights for the purpose of larger good. Thus, simplistic hedonistic calculations have given way to more nuanced understanding of property rights over the years.