Topper Copies

Lateral entry into civil services is seen as a reformative step, yet it continues to attract criticism and controversy. Discuss.

Vaibhav Singh, AIR 82, 2024

Lateral entry into civil services allows for non-career bureaucrats to join the government at middle-level of bureaucracy. This allows for greater industry experience to join government workforce and allowing for technocrats to contribute to national development.

Reformative Potential

1. The erstwhile system of allowing only career bureaucrats to reach higher-level management in bureaucracy had prevented talent from the private sector from joining the government. 2. With 2017 new lateral entry policy, government was able to attract at Joint Secretary and Director level, talents with industry experience like Pharma, automobiles, etc. 3. This brought forth a nuanced understanding in the government policy making.

The Challenges

1. The concerns of low-pays (in comparison to private sector) and lobbying faced at hands of career bureaucrats has put many applicants at unease. 2. This has led to limited number of applicants with government often not finding anyone eligible. 3. Political compulsions led to cancellation of around 40 posts due to concerns over lack of reservations.

The Way Forward

1. Since there is an undeniable need for lateral entries, it can be furthered by ensuring: - a) direct induction to IAS at mid-level to attract talent rather than ad-hoc basis appointments of few years - b) providing better pay-scales that match the industry-level pays. - c) ensuring subject-matter specialists on AI, Agriculture, etc. are drawn from industry without hassles of usual recruitment processes.

The idea of Viksit Bharat requires a talented Karmayogi Bureaucracy. Here, the idea of lateral entry is a good start.