Topper Copies

The tenets of independent judiciary, life-breath of constitutional democracy, stand perpetually undermined by the executive encroachment into the judicial domain. Discuss.

Utkarsh Pathak, AIR 179, 2025

Independent judiciary is cornerstone of our democracy. and it is the key principle of separation of power among different organs of state that ensure a healthy and functional democay.

Tenets of Independent judiciary

However, encroachment of executive undermine judicial independence 1. Reverting judicial pronouncements through legislatures - examples are- recent reversal of judgement of selection of election commissioner through Election Commission (conditions of service) Act 2024 - Reversal of judgement in Government of NCT of Delhi case where SC gave authority in appointment is service matter to Delhi government. 2. Subsuming key role in judicial appointment - through NJAC Act, however it was nullified by SC. 3. Delay in judicial appointment - It further undermines judicial strength and its independence. 4. Objection on certain recommendations proposed by collegium leads to delay in appointments. 5. Limiting power of judiciary - Examples are- 42nd CAA, 25th CAA limited judicial review power of court with respect to constitutional amendment Act - The provisions for tribunal limited appeal to SC, However got struck in L. Chandra Kumar case. 6. Executive role in determining terms of service conditions, salary etc further highlight role of executive. 7. The insufficent status of infrastructure as highlighted by CJI Chandrachud also highlight role of executive as- 30%. lower judiciary lack separate women toilet.

However steps have been taken to ensure the separation of power 1. Judicial pronouncements - like K.Bhaeti case, Minerva Mill case struck down provision taking judicial review away., also establish doctrine of Basic structure. 2. SC assumed power of appointment through collegium. (3rd Judges case). 3. MoP between Ministry of law and SC highlighting procedure for appointment. 4. Constitutional provision as discussed above.

Independent judiciary act as the guardian of Indian democracy ensuring a balance of power among different state organs.