Topper Copies

How will you explain that Indian federalism is a happy mix of Unitarianism and confederalism?

Utkarsh Pathak, AIR 179, 2025

Nature of polity of Indian state is defined by Article 1 as union of states. It has further been termed as Quasi-federal by K.C. Wheare which indicate elements of both Unitarinism & confedaelism.

A happy mix of Unitarianism & confedaelism 1) Unitary feature- 1. Integrated nature of judiciary like in U.K. 2. Certain provision like article 352, 356 which gives power to centre over state affairs under certain emergencies, 3. Article 2,3,4 of constitution which allows centre to change name, area and boundary of states. 4. All India services, provision of GST further give a unitary feature. 5. Single citizenship, single flag. 6. More subject in Union list and doctrine of federal supremacy.

2) Confederal feature (powers with states) 1. Article 246 - clearly demarcates power of states where they have exclusive subject matter jurisdiction. 2. Constitutional Amendment (A/368) - certain provision can't be changed without assent of half of states as- A/246, election of President etc. 3. State to have own State language, separate bodies as - State finance commission, State Public service commission etc 4. State are independent to formulate own policy, take fiscal decision.

Thus, we see a mix of provisions of unitary and confederalism which has been succesful in running world's largest functioning democracy.

As former CJI Chandrachud has said Indian polity is amphibian which changes between unitary and federal as per the need of time.