Despite constitutional backing, urban planning and governance have given limited dividends on the ground. Enumerating the reasons for the same, suggest measures to ameliorate the situation.
Utkarsh Pathak, AIR 179, 2025
74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1991 gave constitutional backing to urban planning and governance by adding schedule 12 to Indian constitution which includes 18 subject of planning & governance with powers given to municipalties subject to state will.
Despite this provision the results are not in proportion and only limited success as - 1. urban planning is not upto future needs (Population - 2 times by 2050) 2. governance is marked by inefficiencies - poor provision of services as- Roads, housing, water etc 3. financial performance also questionable
Reasons for this limited success 1. Municipalties lack financial autonomy - - Depend upon state for financial resources. - State don't allocate insufficient funds - SFC is not formed periodically. 2. Lack of devolution of functions - State feel shy in delegating powers to municipality eg- subject like road etc not in its purview 3. Para-statal body - they hijack the functioning of municipality eg - Delhi Jal Board. 4. Elite capture of power - These bodies are overwhelmed by MPs, MLAs. 5. Lack of dedicated & trained manpower- It affects its efficient functioning. 6. Bureaucratic hijack of functioning - elected members don't get to have a say in crucial decisions. 7. State apathy- as- lack of timely elections - dissolving before stipulated time 8. Poor resources of ones - as poor civic tax collection - property tax collection is meagre
Measures to ameliorate 1. Devolution of functions & finances by states- - SFC regularly formed and recommendation are followed 2. Tap into Municipalties own resources - eg - Pune Municipality, Lucknow Municipality floated municipal bonds. - Survey of property - explore civic fines. 3. Dedicated cadre to address Human resources issue- as- Rajasthan has a dedicated cadre. 4. ARC-II - suggest abolishing para-statal bodies and also ending MLA & MP Local area development fund. (LADS). 5. Capacity building of Municipalties - Through use of ICT where experts can communicate. - push for research & development to come up with solutions to challenges Urban areas are facing - as- clean water, pollution etc. 6. Establish a city economic council to further improve financial aspect
Municipalties seen as a vital unit of governance, there effective functioning will help facilitate democracy at grassroot level.