Topper Copies

The critical reason for poor public health indicators in India goes beyond recognition of right to health as fundamental right. Do you think that a statutory framework alone can ameliorate the situation?

Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024

Poor public health indicators such as hunger, public expenditure and maternal health showcases poor health of the country

Reasons for poor health indicators : 1. High Out of pocket Expenditure (OOP) - around 60% - leading to vicious cycle of poverty and hunger. 2. Low government spending on healthcare - 2.1% of GDP - leading to poor health infrastructure. 3. Shortage of nurses and doctors due to limited seats in institutions. 4. Irregular and unhealthy diet due to less awareness and interaction - 5. Regional variations - such as rural-urban divide. 6. Poor socio-economic indicators.

Statutory framework can ameliorate the situation by : 1. Obligation to provide timely, acceptable, affordable and quality heathcare 2. Improved access to services. 3. Reduced budget squeeze - affordable diets and spending on education -> low poverty and viscious cycle. 4. Research in newer disease - improved indicators. 5. Increased expenditure by the states to provide Right to Health 6. Accountabelity of officials, medical practitioners.

However, statutory framework is inadequate 1. Poor health infrastructure - difficulty in the implementation 2. Limited government fiscal capacity to spend in healthcare. 3. Limited trained healthcare workers to provide service to population 4. Inadequate focus on preventive health and more focus on post disease care 5. Poor adoption of indigenous systems such as AYUSH which can supplement the sector.

The Rajasthan government proposal of Right to Health is a good step in this regard which seeks to provide affordable healthcare to all. Since health is a state subject, interventions similar to this are needed from state governments.