The Constitution of India provides several rights that empower the individual, yet it balances these freedoms with reasonable restrictions in the larger public interest. Discuss how constitutional restrictions on fundamental rights strike a fine balance between individual interests and societal interests. Also, mention the principles that are considered in evaluating the reasonableness of restrictions with reference case laws.
Neelesh Goyal, AIR 77, 2024
Equality means, no person is so placed in society that he can overreach to an extent, that consitute denial of rights to another person. - Rousseau
This is the crux of fundamental rights provided in our constitution. They provide right to individual but restrict him from causing denial of another's rights.
Constitutional rights & restrictions : a fine balance
1. Freedom to speech and expression - Art 19(1)(a) provides FoSE but under Art 19(2) provides reasonable restrictions such as - public law & order, defamation, morality etc. - this helps avoiding hate speeches that can create social tension. 2. Freedom of movement & residence - Restrictions are there on the basis of public health, morality and protection to natives (tribal areas) 3. Freedom of religion - Restrictions on the basis of Secularism. does not include right to convert. 4. Right to life and public liberty - Provides dignified life to individual but restrictions on acts such as - Suicide, active euthanasia
Principles considered : evaluating reasonableness of restrictions
1. Rule of law - lack of arbitrary powers to executives - eg SC in Meneka Gandhi case (1980) declared that reasonable restrictions can't be other than mentioned in Art 19(2) 2. Due process of law - instead of mere presence of law, reasonability of the law takes precedence. 3. Law of proportionality - measures taken should not be disproportionate with results sought. - eg K.S. Puttaswamy case (2017)
Therefore these reasonable restrictions on individual rights have strengthened the social well-being.