Topper Copies

While rankings aim to benchmark the performance of Higher Education Institutions (HEIs), concerns remain about whether current ranking frameworks reflect the broader goals of education. Suggest measures to make the ranking system more objective, inclusive, and aligned with educational and societal outcomes.

Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025

Currently, only 40% of Higher Educational institutions (HEIs) have voluntarily opted for accreditation by NAAC.

Concerns with current ranking framework

1. Skewed criteria : NIRF focus on output (publications) not outcomes 2. Quantitative criteria overshadows qualitative : no. of labs, faculties etc. 3. Broader goal of creating research-based HEIs not reflected : as rankings based on # [?] academic papers, rather than quality of papers. 4. Conflict of interest : as NAAC inspection team includes former or present academics. 5. Lack of Training of inspection Teams - lead to undue influence, manipulation by private colleges 6. Corruption - institutions pay for good rankings.

To make ranking frameworks better

1. improve objectivity through: - set criteria with weight assigned in line with education goals - use digital tools for data collection and recording - can prevent tampering (Eg) blockchain. 2. inclusive criteria through: - focus on gender ratio in Faculty currently only 46 females while 77 males. - criteria to include "SC/ST discrimination free" as a goal. - curb ragging on campus - get bonus marks 3. alignment with socio-educational outcomes - more weightage to socially-relevant research - criteria on social entrepreneurship promotion by HEI -

As a way Forward, NEP 2020 must include reform of NIRF as a first stepping stone to a vibrant HE institution. (goal of 35% GER by 2035)