Topper Copies

The cooperative nature of Indian federalism is being increasingly challenged by emerging differences in Centre-State relations. Discuss. What steps can be taken to strengthen the cooperative spirit of Indian federalism?

Neelesh Goyal, AIR 77, 2024

Prof. K.C. wheare described Indian polity - quasi federalism. It has almost all the feature of a pure federal polity.

Co-operative nature of Indian federalism

1. Centre taking steps for empowerment (social & economic) of states - eg special state status 2. Centre taking up welfare responsibilites of states. - eg Central sponsored schemes 3. States co-operating with centre - eg During COVID-19, one nation, one ration card

However, there are challanges to this co-operative federalism

1. Devolution of funds - states want more share from the divisible pool. - eg at present 42% (15th FC), states want >60%. 2. GST council - states are not in agreement with centre due to decline in their revenue collection. 3. Institution of Governor - States argue that it is being used by centre against democratically elected state govt. - eg State of West Bengal, Tamil nadu 4. Implementation of welfare schemes - some states have not implemented central schemes - eg PM-JAY not implemented - West Bengal

Steps : to strengthen spirit of Indian federalism

1. Governor should be from non-political background. - (Sarkaria commission) 2. In the matters of concurrent list, centre must not intervene, until its too urgent. - (II ARC) 3. Hydrocarbon products such as - petrol, diesel - should be kept out of GST -> states can earn revenue. 4. NITI aayog, as a think tank should listen to states' grievances and come up with solutions. 5. In the matters of health, education women safety, central laws should be implemented.

Therefore, a strong federation will result in a prosperous India.