"The Basic Structure Doctrine, lauded for safeguarding the core principles of the Constitution against majoritarian impulses, is also criticized for enabling judicial overreach and disturbing the balance of power as envisioned by the Constitution." Elaborate.
Neelesh Goyal, AIR 77, 2024
Supreme Court in Kesvananda Bharati Vs sate of kerala case 1973 gave the doctrine of Basic structure. As per this doctrine can't any amendment to the constitution alter its basic structure.
Basic structure doctrine: Safeguarding the constitution against majoritarian impulses
1. Ensuring judicial independence - struck down 99th CAA (NJAC) 2. Freedom of speech and expression - eg Put stay on centre's notification of Fact check Unit (2024) 3. Not allowing practices unconducive for federal democracy. - eg stopping misuse of Art 356 4. Ensuring gender justice and equality - eg Triple talaq case, Shayra bano case 5. Upholding free and fair election principles. - eg Indira Gandhi Vs Rajnarain case (1975) 6. Upholding secularism - eg Kanwar yatra route, UP - SC order administration to take back its order of displaying owner name
However, in some cases, it has also been criticized for : judicial overreach and disturbing balance of power:
1. NJAC case - led to judges appointing judges (uncle judge syndrome) 2. Judicial overreach in religious matter - eg 2021 -> SC ordered demolition of Ravidas temple in Delhi - had to retract after huge protests. 3. Disturbing balance of power between judiciary and executive - eg Anup Baranwal case - CJI made part of committee to appoint CEC, India.
Therefore, as per Article 50, seperation of judiciary and executives is recommended.