Critically examine the 'in-house procedure' adopted by the Apex Court to inquire into allegations of misconduct against judges of constitutional courts in India.
Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025
In House Memorandum (1999) was adopted by judiciary to inquire into allegations of misconduct by judges.
content of Memorandum
1. On complaint of misconduct, supreme court to constitute 3-member inquiry committee 2. enquiry committee to include SC judge, High Court Judge or even a distinguished jurist 3. Follow principles of natural justice 4. No complaint to be registered unless SC directs. 5. No requirement to make the inquiry report public. 6. Transfer or non-allotment of judicial work during pending
Lacunae in the procedure
1. No Transparency : closed door consultations (Eg) in Ranjan Gogoi sexual harassment allegation 2. No timelines : Justice Yashwant Varma case still no progress 3. Enforcement powers lacking : judiciary has no police force of own 4. Tap on the knuckle : no deterrence as judges merely transferred till case pending 5. Conflict of interest : judges deciding case against colleagues (against Principles of Natural Justice)
Suggestions
1. statutory body [National Judicial Council in US] to inquire 2. Lokpal be granted jurisdiction over judges - first constitutionalise lokpal 3. Restatement of Judicial Values (1997) - be framed into a binding Code of Judicial conduct - (Eg) To curb hate speech cases by judges seen recently.
The judges must also be subject to rule of law (A V Dicey). "Accountable institutions script the destiny of nation".