Topper Copies

The evolution of property rights in India reflects an intricate relationship that exists between individual rights and public welfare. Discuss this statement with the help of relevant constitutional provisions and case laws.

Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025

Right to property is recognized as a constitutional right under Art. 300A of the Constitution.

Evolution

- 1949 : fundamental Right under Art. 19(1)(F) + Art. 31 prevented encroachment - ↓ - 19[?] : 1st constitution Amendment 195[6?] permitted expropriation (added Art. 31 A,B) - 1978 : 44th Constitution Amendment 1978 relegated it to a legal right - abolished fundamental right

Intricate relationship between rights and public welfare

1. Doctrine of Eminent Domain : permits state to acquire private property for public purpose 2. Directive Principles [39 (b) and (c)] to have overriding effect on Art. 14, 19 - state can ensure property not concentrated

However, the judiciary has balanced above public welfare with individual rights:

1. Appropriate and just compensation must be paid [KT Plantation v/s State of Karnataka] 2. Acquisition only for public purpose - if Fraudulent motive, void [?] [State of Rajasthan v/s Basant Nahata] 3. Not all private property is "material resource of the community" [Property owners' Association v/s State of Maharashtra (2025)]

Thus, legislative powers to acquire property in public welfare balanced with individual property rights.