The Representation of People's Act, the bedrock of free and fair elections in the country, has failed to keep pace with the contemporary challenges. Highlighting the shortcomings in the legislation, suggest reforms to make it more effective.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Two pieces of legislations: - RPA, 1950 - RPA, 1951 were enacted to be the bedrock of free & fair elections in the society going forward. - However, those laws have not been able to fulfill their promises:
Issues pertinent today 1. criminalization of Politics - >44% mPs have criminal charges (ADR Report) - Impact: - Lesser woman participation - Honest people are uninterested - Stigmatized politics - money and muscle power 2. Added to the problem of unsuitable legislators; the issues of public don't get adequate attention by Representatives 3. Parties favouring the winnability of candidates over suitability; despite repeated requests & direction from supreme court 4. ECI is still a toothless body - can't legally Enforce many of the provisions required for 'Free and Fair elections'
shortcomings in RPA, 1951 1. NO power of. Deregistration of corrupt Political parties to ECI - ECI can only register 2. ECI can't Enforce MCC (modal code of conduct) legally - Freebies Politics - strain of public money - False promises by parties (Immoral & should be: Illegal) 3. too tedious procedure for DisQualification of MP/MLAs (section 8) - election petition can be filed in HC only after completion of Process - multiple Authorities: - courts & continuous appeals - Final decision with President (on ECI advice) - Even ECI can grant some concession 4. No time frame for dispute settlement - candidates even complete their term despite being involved in unfair Practices 5. Practices like Defamation and Rape have same period of disqualification of 6 years - not justified
Thus, time and again, ECI and S.C. along with Civil society groups have requested Govt. to bring reforms. - Law Commission: - Simplification of Procedure for Disqualification - Set up dedicated trial courts - Limit the number of Appeals - Deregisitration power to ECI - Pre-Emptive Trials/Judgements even before completion of Election cycle
Thus, Free & Fair Elections are sine qua-non for Electoral Democracy.