Topper Copies

Why was parliamentary form of government adopted for independent India? Do you agree with the opinion that Indian government is increasingly transitioning towards presidential form? Justify.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

The Parliamentary form of Government means that the Executive Branch is responsible to the Legislature, which has all the Elected representatives from the country. Ex: India, Britain, etc. vs. In Presidential Systems, the President (& his council) is not responsible to legislature.

Why did India adopt such system 1. Familiarity with system: - UK already practised this form - Indians also gained experience before Independence 2. Lesser Clashes between Executive and Legislature - B.R. Ambedkar was of view that having a Bipolar system would lead to further disruptions which an Aspirational society like India couldn't afford, given our limited & resources 3. In a presidential system; - President becomes too powerful - Legislature can't act as a system of checks in case of Arbitrary actions 4. Swaran Singh committee: - was established to ponder upon whether India should move towards a presidential setup and it didn't favour the proposal 5. No continuity in policies & cohesion - President makes own laws - Congress makes different laws - Power Rivalry sometimes and sometimes Presidential despotism

* Recently, some allegation made that India also becoming kind of Presidential system -> 1. High Centricity towards a Single person: pm (feature of Presidential system) 2. Declining control of Parliament over the Executive - committees referral (down) - Days of Sitting (down) - Partisan role of speaker (up) 3. Increasing usage of ordinance, etc.

* However the Idea can be disproved: 1. Executive is still dependent on Legislature for - Budget - passing laws 2. Rajya Sabha has held strongly to protection from Arbitrary laws of Executive 3. multi-party system has kept the Parliamentary Democracy alive

Thus, the phenomena is not absolute however, some tendencies need to be pondered upon immediately.