Topper Copies

What do you understand by the First Past the Post System (FPPS)? Why was FPPS preferred over the Proportional Representation (PR) system for elections to the Lok Sabha/Vidhan Sabha? Also, critically examine the consequences of this preference.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

There are 2 systems prominently used to Elect representatives out of a voting mechanism: FPTP and Proportional system.

FPTP -> Herein, from a Constituency, the Candidate which secures the most number of votes, is elected the representative of that constituency to Loksabha, Vidhan Sabha. However, at the Govt. level, these Electors choose their Elected leaders as CM/PM.

why FPTP was chosen 1. Easy to understand by common public especially at time of Independence; we had 80% Illeteracy 2. Familiarity with the system - Already in 1937 elections, etc. Indians knew about the system and shifting to Proportional system didn't make sense 3. Leads to strong connect between the Elected representative and his Constituency (vs. Proportional system) - voters (citizens) know whom to approach for their Issues - They can hold their representatives more accountable 4. local Representative understands the issues better vs. a nationalistic Pool based system of shared seats

However, the system is not-fool proof 1. Leads to majoritarianism: - Get most votes; get Elected - NO Requirement of securing min. 50% votes in constituency 2. often minorities (voter group) are under-represented at both local and National levels - Even if minorities may make 49%, of the national population; it is possible technically, that they don't get represented at diff. levels aptly 3. Reduction in Significance of value of Political Parties vis-a-vis a Candidate's personal Political stature - Often the Parties' Ideologies are ignored by the voters and they tend to vote for 'Bahubali Leaders'

- Thus, a time has reached wherein we can hold discussions for a mixed systems using the both avenues - many countries like nepal, etc. have already started - however, Political stability and Consensus building must be given Providence first