Frequent reliance on the ordinance making power by the government, not only dilutes the basic tenets of executive accountability in a parliamentary democracy, but also overlooks the democratic traditions of building consensus. Discuss with relevant examples.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Article 123 at Parliament level and 213 at state level allows for President or Governor to pass ordinance. - Recently, Govt. of India passed an ordinance in may 2023 forming NCCSA thereby reducing the powers of elected govt. of Delhi in his control over Civil servants. - one of the farm Bills was also passed by ordinance.
Challenges Associated 1. By passing Legislature in a parliamentary Democracy 2. Passing ordinance when Supreme court goes for Recess. (Ex: Delhi '23) 3. Reduces the legislative control over Executive - Hurts the Basic Structure and values of Constitutionalism: Limited Govt. 4. Decline in healthy democratic traditions of consensus building by Debates and facts
Supreme Court has taken a very tough stance over this pressing Issue: 1. DC wadhwa vs. State of Bihar: - Repromulgating ordinances and trying to bypass Legislature is un-constitutional! - (currently, within 6 weeks of reassembly of Houses; the ordinance needs to be tabled before Legislature. - S.C. has also ruled that the satisfaction of President and Governor is subject to Judicial Review.
Thus, Ordinance is a tool for some Extraordinary circumstances when Legislature is not in session; it must be treated as a 'Dead letter'