Topper Copies

What do you mean by 'doctrine of essentiality'? How has judiciary used this doctrine to address conflict between various fundamental rights? Explain with examples.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

Essential Religious Practice is a Judicial Innovation to balance the Rights available to a citizen and other Considerations.

Court to balance: - In the Shirur mutt Judgement, 1954 Hon'ble court delivered this doctrine that all those practices which are considered non-Essential to the Religion's core - won't be allowed by the court. - Subsequently, in the Triple Talak Judgement: court said that the Religion didn't allow impinging upon Female's Dignity & equality of Rights and termed its unconstitutional. - In the sabrimala verdick, S.C. allowed the Entry of Females of mostly menstruating Age-Group and said the Hindu Religion doesn't sanction this. - supremacy of Article 14 along with Article 25 to Individuals.

However, there are several objections 1. Experts say if the court is Expert enough to be able to understand the Religious Scriptures in detail 2. Too much of Judicial Activism 3. Article 25 is compromised for a large set of people

The Hizab controversy is currently Subjudice in S.C. and it would be worth seeing how S.C balances between Equality, Freedom of Expression, etc among other values & rights.