Topper Copies

Subordination of investigative agencies to the executive is fraught with disastrous consequences. Discuss the statement in light of the criticism of the Central Bureau of Investigation as a "caged parrot".

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

Recently supreme Court's criticism of CBI as 'Caged Parrot' of centre raised many already existing concerns with respect to issues with such bodies.

challenges associated 1. Political vengeance against opposition leaders 2. NO Accountability to parliament despite Parliamentary democracy (for Ex: In Sweden, Lokpal answers to Parliament only) 3. lack of transparency and reduction in public confidence of such agencies 4. Demotivation to young and honest officers & leadership crisis 5. CBI has very low - Chargesheet File Rate - conviction Rate (below 5%) 6. Leads to hurting the idea of Cooperative Federalism

Hon'ble S.C. has reiterated Federalism is a part of Basic structure and any attempt to hurt this is not a testimony to constitutional Ethos. - S.C. ruled over the appointment process of CBI director.

measures needed & way Ahead 1. more transparency in cases uptake: Put data on website and links to original complaints filed at CVC, Lokpal, etc. 2. Audit by CAG - Even proprietary 3. Following Swedish model of Parliamentary Authority

Thus, strength of Institutional is critical today.