Basic structure doctrine has prevented the Parliament, a creature of the constitution, from becoming the master of the constitution. Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
24 April 1973 marked a landmark in the History of India wherein Hon'ble Supreme court gave the Basic Structure Doctrine in the Keshavanand Bharti Case. - This was in response to court's earlier judgement in Colaknath case 1967: - S.C. took a conservative interpretation and said Fundamental Rights are Sacrosanct and unamendable For which Govt. passed 24th and 25th Constitutional Amendment Acts.
The Doctrine basically gives the idea of constitutionalism i.e. Limited Govt. and unlike British model wherein the Parliament is constitution to a great Extent and there is very less control on Parliamentary Supremacy.
B.S.D. has led to Supremacy of Constitution over either Judicial or parliamentary supremacy.
Evolution 1. Bommai Case : S.C said : - Federalism, secularism, Rule of law are the basic tenets and Can't be meddled with. 2. Indira Gandhi Case - power of Judicial Review - Free and Fair elections are part of B.S.D.
In Keshavanand Bharti Itself, S.C. said: - sovereignity - Division of power and other critical values form B.S.D.
- This has led to a Balance and ensures unchecked parliamentary Supremacy.