Independent judiciary, as envisaged by the constitution, provides the bedrock for a thriving polity; however, executive encroachment may erode its credibility and affect its efficacy. Evaluate.
Kshitij Aditya Sharma, AIR 58, 2024
In Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain, the Supreme court held that an independent judiciary is the foundation of separation of powers, and thus, also a part of the basic structure of the constitution.
Role of independent judiciary
1. upholding the rule of law [AV Dicey-Supremacy of the law is an element of rule of law] 2. Preventing administrative excesses. 3. Upholding fundamental rights & applying reasonable restrictions when required- 4. Foundation of government (executives) accountability towards citizens. 5. Progressive expansion of human rights through article 21.
Threats from executive encroachment
1. During PM Indira Gandhi's term, several judges were overlooked for appointment as CJI. 2. Failure to appoint judges in a timely manner especially to high courts. 3. Refusal to obey the orders of the court. eg Arnesh Kumar case - guidelines on bail. 4. Overruling court verdicts through law eg Delhi NCT ordinance, 2023. 5. Public criticism of the court's functioning by the speaker & vice president.
Way forward
1. government & courts should come up with an agreed Memorandum of appointment of judges. 2. As recommended by the court, new appointments should be made within 3-4 weeks of recommendation by collegium. 3. Avoiding public criticism of the courts functioning. 4. Creation of a National Judicial service for lower judiciary. 5. Legislature must respect SC verdicts, and not overrule them through legislative means.
The courts have time & again upheld the vibrancy of our democracy. The gita says - he who protects the law is protected by it. Thus, we must ensure judicial efficiency & independence.