Topper Copies

"Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a viable solution to eradicate extreme poverty in India." Critically discuss the statement.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

India has largest number of people living under extreme poverty, as per world Bank. UBI, a transfer of monthly amount to all is considered as an effective measure to eradicate extreme poverty.

Utility of UBI in eradicating poverty 1. Provide support for basic necessity eg food grains, 2. Address exclusion - Inclusion error of schemes - eg 40% eligible excluded from PDS (Shanta Kumar Committee) 3. Means of a life of dignity with choice - eg No queing up at ration shop 4. Minimise Administrative touchpoints, reducing Corruption 5. Less expensive to administer using DBT . 6. Promote financial inclusion by universalising bank accounts . 7. Ensure psychological security in case of sudden unemployment 8. Success in Scandenavian countries suggest potential of transformation.

Limitation in addressing Extreme poverty 1. Doesn't build capability, as envisged by Amartya Sen 2. Treat all individuals as equal, disregarding contextual application 3. Limited state resources, deter proper implementation - eg tax to GDP ratio, India 11% against OECD 32% (bar chart) 4. Absolves state of moral responsibility to uplift & build skills 5. Doesn't ensure effective utilisation on intended purposes & misutilisation - a) In kind availability

Thus, we can say that while UBI can be effective, the most effective way would be to build capability